• Home
  • Eat + Drink
  • Music + Nightlife
    • Scene and Heard
    • Your Weekend Dirty Dozen
  • Arts + Entertainment
    • Culture Your Fu**ing Self
    • Hidden in Plain View
  • Tech + Startups
  • News
    • Asshole and Hero of the Week
    • Ben Meets World
    • On The Issues
  • The Team
    • Emma Sullivan – Editor
    • Allison Schaper
    • Ashby Strauch
    • Benjamin Duong
    • Brittany Sgaliardich
    • Camron Thompson
    • Caroline Stonecipher
    • Chelsea Hazlett
    • Claire Fuller
    • Claudia Bell
    • Daniel Harrison
    • Eleanor Samuels
    • Genesis Gonzalez
    • Kathryn Williams
    • Kriti Vedhanayagam
    • Michaela Beeda
    • Mimi Milligan
    • Paige Fry
    • Tara Hempstead
    • Rachel Donohue
    • Renata Coutinho
    • Sari Eichenblatt
    • Taylor Gaines
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram
GainesvilleScene
ZBT-House
Campus Life, News 8

ZBT-Gate: Guilty Until Proven Otherwise

By Kriti Vedhanayagam · On May 12, 2015
  • Tweet
  • Tweet

After four years of college, countless hours at the library and a more-than-passing grade in biochemistry, one of my proudest accomplishments is that I am the owner of a Fall 2014 “Rush ZBT” T-shirt.

I will wear this shirt with no reservations — despite the fact that many would consider it something to be ashamed of, in light of recent events — and I will always keep in mind the U.S. justice system’s creed of “innocent until proven guilty.”

Although it’s been around for ages, the general public ignored that simple notion when the media unleashed yet another fraternity-culture witch hunt, alleging that UF’s ZBT chapter was guilty of anti-veteran actions during its Panama City Beach getaway for Spring formal.

The story had the perfect villains because, these days, everyone hates fraternities and the ostensibly toxic culture they perpetuate.

The media crafted a tale that fit their agenda, ethical reporting standards and practices be damned, taking allegations and portraying them as facts —“facts” that I can’t reconcile with the young men I know in this fraternity. And, yet again, the public rushed to the front row of the media circus, which entails little investigation and a whole lot of assumption.

And even though we’ve all seen the consequences of media sensationalism (remember the Duke lacrosse players of 2006? Or the UVA fraternity men?), we’re still rendered powerless and impressionable at the hand of powerful headlines and veiled accusations.

Via: David Duke

During the week Fox News was camped outside the ZBT house on UF’s fraternity row, ZBT president Tyler Drescher received over 100 death threats and was forced to leave Gainesville and head home early. Police also escorted a strange man out of the house after he was found wandering, asking for the ZBT president.

A day after the story broke, all of the students living in house were asked to vacate the premises for their own safety. The police was stationed outside for weeks afterwards to prevent backlash.

As for those of us existing outside the immediate realm of the scandal, we were all quick to judge. We let the unfortunate outcomes of false accusations of the past slip from our minds, inadvertently contributing to the damage caused by the media.

ZBT-gate may not be as dire as its predecessors, but it’s a fresh example of the dangerous trend of unequivocal scapegoating.

These days, the general public chooses to blindly accept allegations and assume the worst about men, especially those who belong to fraternities in our nation’s many universities. It should, instead, take facts at face value and view each case individually.

Claims that fraternities are hotbeds of sin and dens of evil, full of entitled and privileged white males, aren’t entirely baseless. They are not immune to groupthink. Some would even argue that they are uniquely vulnerable to the phenomenon — a large proportion of members are under 21 and most others, if not all, are under 25, the age which most psychologists claim the adult mind reaches maturation.

The men of ZBT I’m personally acquainted with are high-achieving young men with impressive GPAs. They regularly engage in philanthropic efforts. They create a culture of brotherhood, which its members carry for decades beyond the day they graduate from UF.

They’re good people.

I have had the privilege of befriending and watching this particular group of men, complete strangers before college, become a support system for each other within a few short weeks.

I have overheard various conversations, where older brothers counseled younger brothers, encouraging them to stay the course in challenging areas of study or advising them in matters of the heart.

Yes, I have also been treated like furniture by brothers who realized I wasn’t a viable sexual prospect. I’ve watched some take drugs, and others act like moronic Neanderthals. But the very same could be said about men who are not part of ZBT, or even the Greek community.

This particular incident was likely little more than a particularly unfortunate scenario of drunk people acting like drunk people.

It was a combination of college shenanigans and U.S. war veterans, made worse by myopic media coverage.

Via: WordPress

Via: WordPress

Veterans are put on a pedestal, and in most regards, rightly so. They’ve sacrificed so much for their country. But holding them in such high regard has made it so even questioning their integrity is sacrilegious.  So we were all quick to throw ZBT members under the bus.

The university chose to view the accused not as individuals, but as a whole; it turned its back on the entire chapter by way of expulsion. Ultimately, UF significantly contributed to the biased treatment of the Greek system.

And the media, in their crusades to further vilify “fraternity culture,” failed to investigate. Instead, they chose to sensationalize. After all, hatred of fraternities has become de rigueur in past years, and not capitalizing on it would simply be bad business.

 Feature photo courtesy of WUFT

controversymedia coveragescandalUF fraternityZeta Beta Tau
Share Tweet
Kriti Vedhanayagam

Kriti Vedhanayagam

"There is only one thing in life worse than being talked about, and that is not being talked about”

You Might Also Like

  • alcohol-492871_640 Events

    Ultimate Drinking Game for the Democratic Debate

  • Via: Unsplash News

    Don’t Keep the Change

  • O Hot This Week

    Where Do the Presidential Candidates Stand on Gun Control?

  • Anonymous

    Your bias for the fraternity could not be anymore obvious. This was the most horrific “report” I have read to date. Not once did you bring an outside source to prove that this was indeed a false accusation. You then went ahead to state that the “general public chooses to blindly accept allegations and assume the worst about men, especially those who belong to fraternities in our nation’s many universities” when in actuality the true issue we face today is the exact opposite, too often the case is that frats get away with date rape because of their false views of the women involved.

    Even worse you then stated, “Veterans are put on a pedestal, and in most regards, rightly so.” If you read any issues veterans are facing today you would quickly realize the inaccuracy in your comment. I’m just going to go on a limb and assume you don’t have any relatives that are veterans. Veterans currently face little no medical aid, here is an outside source to prove my point:
    “The agency tracks and widely reports the average wait time: 273 days. But the
    internal data indicates that veterans filing their first claim, including those
    who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, wait nearly two months longer, between 316
    and 327 days. Those filing for the first time in America’s major population
    centers wait up to twice as long — 642 days in New York, 619 days in Los
    Angeles and 542 days in Chicago.” (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/14/veterans-benefits_n_2875637.html)

    That is just one of the many issues.

    UF’s decision to ban the whole fraternity was not a biased and haste decision. It was an intentional message for all fraternities and sororities to begin (and I can’t emphasize ‘begin’ enough) conducting themselves properly. What you call a biased view against Greek life is a revolutionary view that has just begun, to hold these institutions accountable for their actions.

    It is you that has put this fraternity on a pedestal and have ignored basic journalism ethics to build what I consider an incoherent rant, and in the process you have once again insulted veterans. If you have any respect for yourself and for those that have served their duty you would take take this down.

    Sincerely,
    A disappointed student

    • anonymous

      You proved her point exactly. One of her main points was that people assumed they were guilty from the beginning, totally disregarding the notion of “innocent until proven guilty.” Why is it her responsibility to bring up a source to prove their innocence? The problem with this case was that all the allegations were verbal accusations, nothing with proof. There were inconsistencies in some of the stories, bringing into question the validity of their accusations. Thsee verbal accusations are not enough, from a legal standpoint, to say that they are guilty. If I accuse you of murdering someone out of no where, it is my job to prove that you are guilty of it, not yours to prove that you are innocent.

      What she says about the general public accepting accusations about fraternities as true definitely holds a lot of ground. Frats are an easy target. People will be more likely to believe that a frat did such things, then say, a bunch of kids in chess club. This story was from the beginning, a losing battle for the guys since it is a dream article to the media in terms of gaining attention. A bunch of frat boys pissing and spitting on veterans? How dare frat boys – a bunch of alcoholic, drug abusing, rapist boys do such things to veterans who have risked their lives to protect our country? This outrage led to a total disregard in the notion of innocent until proven guilty, as these guys were labeled as guilty from the start.

      Funny that you mention “basic journalism ethics.” The first few articles (mainly the article on mypanhandle.com) reported the story as if everything was found true. According to “basic journalism ethics” they should not write an article as if it is a report of what happened purely based off accusations by a few people.

      What this comes down to is society’s unwillingness to see cases case by case. Frat boys pissed on veterans? Must be true because frat guys have done A, B, and C in the past. No proof? Well the accusations were made by veterans, and veterans never lie because they are veterans. Some frat boys are good, and some veterans, as much as I hate to say it, aren’t always honest.Just as any group of people, the group of Veterans always hold outliers that don’t follow the same principles that most veterans do.

      This common fallacy in grouping people by category and judging each individual and action based on their group is also the same logic as, you guessed it, racism.
      Imagine that someone accused a Muslim in a airport of planting a bomb after a bombing. Law enforcement will start off by assuming they are guilty. Because hey, we just had another Muslim kill a bunch of our people! it’s an uphill battle for the poor Muslim from there on.

      In regards to your point about veterans not receiving medical care, I sympathize greatly. I have an uncle who served in the military. Although he has been lucky enough to come back healthy, he has complained about, and i have also met a number of his fellow veterans who have struggled with the issue. (Unfortunately, my encounters with some of these men also make me confident in saying that not all veterans are good.) One of the things that bothered me about this case was that our veterans are not always given the respect and proper treatment that they deserve, but in this case they blatantly believed their words with no regards for factual evidence. As if they’ve been treating the veterans like angels all along.

      My main concluding point is this. Frats do some bad that bring negative publicity. That doesn’t mean that all frats are bad, or that everything that frats allegedly did are necessarily true. Next time something like this happens, stay away from labeling them as a frat and bringing along all the negative assumptions about the group of young men. Innocent until proven guilty still stands for these kids. And even if they are found guilty of such actions, don’t put it on the entire fraternity and every individual in it. If you’ve been part of any large group of people, you’ll know that there are some uncontrollable individuals who engage in actions to poorly reflect upon the group. Just because some police officers shot innocent black kids doesn’t mean every police officer should take the burden, and be labeled as a racist murderer.

      I apologize for the long post and some tangents I may have went on, but I hope in the future you keep some of my points in kind.

      • Anonymous

        What is an article with no evidence to back their claim? And to claim the reason why she didn’t present any evidence was because it was only based off eye witness is equally retarded. Your lovely and expansive rant said nothing to debunk these claims. As matter fact the few claims you mentioned were wrong. Eye witness reports were not just from veterans, as mattar fact the person that emailed UF was the head coordinator of the parade that claimed she witnessed this debarchry.
        You know who didn’t debunk the eye witness claims? ZBT. Since the “alleged” event ZBT has failed to protest it did not participate in this. If ZBT knows they’re caught then why the hell is this even up for discussion.
        The hyprocracy in your comment was far too immense for me to actually try to point out all the fallacies.
        As I’m concerned this article was written by someone that will do anything just to talk to over privileged white kids.

        • Gator Student

          It’s almost like you didn’t even read the responses the other person wrote. The point of this article is that there is NO evidence to back up the veteran’s claims yet the mainstream media has picked this up not as an accusation but as a event. Why would ZBT put up a fight when they know they will lose; the media disregards the innocence of fraternities and everyone knows that.

          You’re assuming ZBT is guilty when no investigation has been done. You’re biases blind to you points that the writer is trying to make and you’re perpetuating the problem the writer is pointing out.

  • Joe Delago

    Nice article and well state. I was skeptical about the entire situation I have not seen any video or proof other than he said, she said. I also noticed that the women from the veterans group seemed interested in giving out her web site to raise money. What was a veterans group doing on a quiet vacation in the spring break party capital of the country? What did they think? … that there weren’t going to be partying college kids.. Stupid choice for a vacation spot. I don’t doubt that the kids probably did silly things.. but from what I heard they were all silly things.. no one got hurt.. no rape, no murder etc.. All typical college antics. Well written.. I know Frats do many good things for the community and raise a lot of money for charities. I also heard that the place does not want the veterans group back.. they didn’t say they don’t want the students back… hmmmm. wonder why they don’t want the vets back.

  • Joe Delago

    I can’t wait to see what happens when a UF sports figures screws up and see if the entire team is kicked off campus. Not.

  • anon

    way to be 5 weeks late on this…

  • a veteran

    If this is a publicity stunt, you’re doing it right. Sad that the only way people will read your shitty articles is to post something so blatantly ignorant and revolting.

Connect With Us

MorningScene

Recent comments

  • Jonny Howard on “Boyfriend Season” has Officially Started in Gainesville
  • Gregory Herr on Hidden in Plain View: “Rectify”
  • Brainless Reader on I Spent a Night Sober at Grog
  • Rinky Free on Hidden in Plain View: “Rectify”
  • f0rtylegz on Hidden in Plain View: “Rectify”
Tweets by @GnvScene
  • Write for GNVScene
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram

CATEGORIES

  • Write for GNVScene
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA

GainesvilleScene

Write a Guest Post
Partner with Us
Terms & Conditions
DMCA Policy

Connect

Email Us
Facebook
Twitter
Google+
RSS

Our Friends

Starter Space
Gainesville Media
Gainesville Grub

© 2015 GainesvilleScene. All rights reserved. Website Design by Visible Hub. Apartments in Gainesville
GainesvilleScene is not affiliated in any way with The Gainesville Sun or the University of Florida.